70-year-old jailed for life for killing three lesbian women
The prosecutor told the court that “The motive for the crime was hatred. (Envato, Stock)
A court in Buenos Aires has handed 70-year-old Justo Fernando Barrientos a life sentence for killing three lesbian women and trying to kill a fourth, finding that the 2024 boarding-house arson attack was driven by hatred of the victims’ sexual orientation.
The attack happened during the night of 5 to 6 May 2024 at a boarding house in the Barracas area of Buenos Aires, when an incendiary substance was thrown into a room where the victims were sleeping.
What did the court decide?
Oral Criminal and Correctional Court No. 5 found Barrientos guilty of three murders and one attempted murder, as reported by Buenos Aires Times. The Public Prosecutor’s Office (MPF) said the conviction was made more severe because it was motivated by hostility towards the victims’ sexual orientation, involved extreme cruelty, and used a means that could put the public in danger.
Pamela Cobbas died on 6 May 2024. Mercedes Roxana Figueroa died two days later, and Andrea Amarante died on 12 May 2024. All three died from severe burns caused by the attack.
Sofía Castro Riglos, 52, survived, but sustained burns to three per cent of her body and was in hospital for nearly a month. She did not attend the trial.
In closing arguments in October, prosecutor Juan Manuel Fernández Buzzi told the court: “The motive for the crime was hatred. This was not an ordinary homicide: he deliberately set them on fire, with the aim of burning them alive, making them suffer and die in agony.”

Fernández Buzzi added: “They were subjected to harassment and discrimination by Barrientos because they were lesbians and because they were women.”
Barrientos addressed the court before hearing his sentence, saying: “Listen: I feel innocent, that’s all I can tell you.”
How lawyers and rights groups reacted
Luciana Sánchez, a lawyer representing Castro Riglos and Cobbas, called the conviction “a very important recognition,” but added: “The recognition of this as a hate crime motivated by the victims’ sexual orientation is an important first step. The National Judiciary has an enormous debt to repay, and the sentence is not enough to satisfy us.”
Amnesty International Argentina also welcomed the verdict, saying it “sets a historic precedent in the judicial response to lesbicides,” while criticising the court for not applying the aggravating circumstance of gender-based violence.
The court is set to publish the full reasoning behind the verdict on 19 February, 2027.
In a separate case, in October 2023, a man who pleaded guilty to setting an LGBTQ+ bar on fire was sentenced to 48 months in prison, followed by three years of supervised release.