Unnecessary surgery on intersex kids causes ‘permanent harm’

Illustrated rainbow pride flag on a pink background.

Unnecessary surgeries on intersex kids are causing ā€œpermanent harmā€, according to a new report.

The report from the Human Rights Watch and interACT found that doctors in the US continue to perform unnecessary surgery on intersex children.

Titled ā€˜I Want To Be Like Nature Made Meā€™, the 160 page report looks at damage caused by the controversial surgeries which have gone on for decades.

This is despite the surgeries being unnecessary and controversial even within the medical community.

Unnecessary surgery on intersex kids causes ‘permanent harm’

It is estimated that 1.7 percent of babies could be identified as intersex, and the surgeries are usually performed in order to allow the child to grow up ā€œnormalā€.

The report describes the results of the surgeries as ā€œoften catastrophicā€, and says the benefits are ā€œlargely unprovenā€ and it is ā€œrarely urgentā€ for the health of the child.

ā€œThe devastation caused by medically unnecessary surgery on intersex infants is both physical and psychological,ā€ said Kimberly Zieselman, an intersex woman and executive director of interACT.

ā€œDespite decades of patient advocates putting the medical community on notice about the harm from these procedures, many doctors continue to present these surgeries to parents as good options.ā€

The report states that the removal of testicles, which the child would be unable to consent to, is equal to sterilisation without consent.

It also can result in the requirement of lifelong hormone replacement therapy.

Many doctors understand that parents may no longer wish to inflict the surgery on their child.


A doctor who works on a team which works on cases of ā€˜differences of sex developmentā€™ told Human Rights Watch: ā€œWeā€™re listening to the adult patients who are telling us that they feel they were mistreated and mutilated and thatā€™s a very powerful thing.ā€

The report goes on to note an urgent need to address discrepancies in the standards of care for people born intersex.

ā€œThe medical community has made progress in intersex care in recent decades, but medically unnecessary irreversible surgeries on children and infants remain common,ā€ said Kyle Knight, researcher at Human Rights Watch and author of the report.

ā€œThe pressure to fit in and live a ā€˜normalā€™ life is real, but there is no evidence that surgery delivers on the promise of making that easier, and ample evidence that it risks causing irreversible lifelong harm.ā€

This new film reveals the truth about children raised without gender

Earlier this year in the US, a federal district court allowed an intersex person the right to reopen a lawsuit over a gender-neutral passport.