Bakery to pay $12,000 after refusing to make wedding cake for lesbian couple

A wedding cake is displayed as members of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, intersex and queer (LGBTIQ) community take part in the Zurich Pride on September 4, 2021 ahead of a nationwide votation o

A Bakersfield bakery has agreed to pay $12,000 and change its sales policy after it allegedly refused to sell a “generic, multi-purpose white cake” to a lesbian couple for their wedding.

The California Civil Rights Department (CRD) said on 17 November it had reached a settlement with the bakery Tastries to resolve a lawsuit over the business’s refusal to serve to Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio. The terms are set out in a court-filed proposed consent decree.

CRD director Kevin Kish said: “In California, we don’t turn people away because of who they love or where they come from.” He added: “This settlement shows that California is open to business for all.”

Why did the case against Tastries begin?

CRD said that in 2017 Tastries refused to sell a plain white cake that could be used for any occasion to the couple to celebrate their wedding. The department said the bakery refused as it had a policy in place that meant they would not to sell cakes for celebrations of same-sex unions.

The couple filed a complaint with CRD, alleging they were refused service based on their sexual orientation. After investigating, CRD said it found cause to believe Tastries had violated state civil rights law and sued the bakery in 2018.

female same sex wedding
The bakery must now pay $12,000 in fees and damages. (Getty Images, stock)

The case then ran through the courts for years. A trial court ruled in favour of the bakery in late 2022, before an appellate court ruled in favour of the state in 2025. CRD said the California Supreme Court denied a review of the decision, with the US Supreme Court also denying a review in the same year.

What does the settlement require Tastries to do?

Under the settlement, Tastries agreed to provide non-customised products, including cakes, to all customers regardless of their sexual orientation or any other protected characteristics.

The bakery must also attend annual civil rights trainings provided by CRD, post CRD notices about civil rights protections in-store, notify CRD of any discrimination complaints, and report annually on compliance. Tastries will pay $12,000 in damages and fees.

CRD is California’s civil rights enforcement agency (formerly the Department of Fair Employment and Housing) and handles discrimination complaints and litigation under state law, including protections based on sexual orientation and gender identity or expression.

A similar dispute played out in Oregon after a bakery refused to make a wedding cake for a lesbian couple, with Sweet Cakes by Melissa being fined $135,000 (£106,000), later reduced to $30,000 (£23,600).

Please login or register to comment on this story.