Kim Davis allegedly hid property to avoid paying gay couple owed $565k

MOREHEAD, KY - SEPTEMBER 2: Kim Davis, the Rowan County Clerk of Courts, listens to Robbie Blankenship and Jesse Cruz as they speak with her at the County Clerks Office on September 2, 2015 in Morehe

Kim Davis has been accused of transferring inherited land to relatives to avoid paying more than $565,000 owed to the same-sex couple she refused to marry, as Liberty Counsel insists there is no basis for the allegation.

The former Rowan County, Kentucky clerk still owes David Ermold and David Moore over $565,000 in damages, attorney fees and costs stemming from her refusal to issue them a marriage licence in 2015, shortly after the US Supreme Court’s marriage equality ruling in Obergefell v. Hodges.

A federal magistrate judge has ordered Davis to explain allegedly false or incomplete asset disclosures, warning she could face sanctions. Liberty Counsel, the conservative Christian legal group representing Davis, defended her responses.

What is Kim Davis accused of hiding?

In court filings, Ermold and Moore, via their attorneys, allege Davis inherited a 50 per cent interest in her mother’s estate, including interests in three parcels of land worth more than $400,000, then transferred deeds to family members to conceal assets and avoid paying the judgment.

The row focuses on three deeds Davis signed months before telling the couple’s attorneys that she had not transferred any property valued at more than $2,000. Those deeds indicate that, in April and May 2025, she moved her interests in three parcels from her late mother’s estate, during the five-year window covered by the couple’s information request.

In a November 6 order, US Magistrate Judge Edward B. Atkins concluded that certified public records conflicted with Davis’ responses that she held no real estate, had not made any transfers over $2,000, and was not the beneficiary of any trust or estate. He also found she failed to correct or supplement her disclosures, as required under federal rules.

MOREHEAD, KY - SEPTEMBER 2:  Kim Davis, the Rowan County Clerk of Courts, listens to Robbie Blankenship and Jesse Cruz as they speak with her about getting a marriage license at the County Clerks Offi
David Ermold and David Moore more than $565,000 in damages, attorney fees and costs after Kim Davis refused to issue them a marriage licence in 2015, (Getty Images)

Davis denied any wrongdoing in a declaration, writing: “I had no intent then, and have no intent now, to conceal anything or to otherwise answer in any way other than the truth”.

How are Davis and Liberty Counsel responding?

Liberty Counsel argued sanctions should be denied, saying: “The court should deny sanctions because Davis has shown no intent to mislead or conceal anything and answered all questions in the discovery process in good faith”.

Davis also wrote in a legal declaration that the properties “belonged to my mother” and that she and her brother ensured they were given to the individuals her mother requested.

Liberty Counsel founder Mat Staver said: “The claim that Kim Davis is hiding an inheritance or concealing property ownership is not true and not supported by the facts…. Davis was involved in ordinary estate administration, not asset concealment.”

Michael J. Gartland, an attorney for Ermold and Moore, told the Kentucky Lantern: “This is all made up to try to get out of trouble now.”

Davis became internationally known in 2015 after refusing to issue marriage licences “under God’s authority”. In 2022, a federal judge ruled she violated same-sex couples’ constitutional rights by denying licences, and she spent five days in jail for contempt after defying a court order. In January 2024, she was ordered to pay more than $260,000 in legal fees and expenses on top of the $100,000 in damages already awarded to Ermold and Moore.