Montana judge blocks enforcement of bill that defines sex as binary
The complaint challenging SB 437 was filed on 6 April, the state’s response was filed on 22 May, and a preliminary injunction hearing was held on 19 June in Missoula. (Envato, Stock)
A Montana judge has ordered the state to stop enforcing a 2025 law that defines sex as binary based on a person’s reproductive system, granting a preliminary injunction while a legal challenge proceeds.
Missoula County District Court Judge Leslie Halligan granted the injunction on Tuesday, blocking enforcement of Senate Bill 437 while litigation continues. Helena-based Upper Seven Law filed the lawsuit for a group of transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans.
In her written order, Halligan said the injunction would “avert inconsistent enforcement of a statute that plaintiffs have shown is likely unconstitutional”.
SB 437 amended wide-ranging sections of Montana law to include new definitions of “male”, “female”, “sex” and “gender”. The law says “gender” must be treated as meaning the same as “sex” as the legislation defines it, and must not be treated as meaning the same as a person’s gender identity, experienced gender, gender expression or gender role.
What did the judge say about SB 437?
Halligan wrote that the relevant question was not whether SB 437 contains “precisely the same words” as an earlier law, but whether any differences alter the constitutional analysis.
While the definitions are not the same, she wrote that the “operative effect” appears to be the same, imposing a “state-mandated binary classification of sex that, under this court’s prior ruling, infringes on Montanans’ right to define their own gender identity”.

“The court has found that plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims that SB 437 violates the rights to privacy and equal protection and that enforcement will cause ongoing irreparable harm,” Halligan wrote.
Plaintiffs argued that the new law is unconstitutional and requires them to disclose private medical information. The state argued SB 437 does not demand access to private information.
How is Montana defending the law?
In a statement attributed to governor Greg Gianforte and House Speaker Brandon Ler, they said: “This law codifies the long-recognized, commonsense, immutable, biologically-based definition of sex, male and female, while protecting people born intersex and not infringing on transgender individuals’ ability to identify with whatever gender, but not sex, they wish”.
The statement continued: “To no one’s surprise, activists have moved to add this law into ongoing litigation to stop it from going into effect. … The State of Montana will defend this duly enacted law and ensure it gets a fair hearing in Montana’s judiciary.”
The complaint challenging SB 437 was filed on 6 April, the state’s response was filed on 22 May, and a preliminary injunction hearing was held on 19 June in Missoula.
The bill is described as largely similar to 2023’s Senate Bill 458, which was declared unconstitutional in June 2024 and again in February 2025. When SB 458 was signed into law in 2023, its wording was compared to legislating that Earth is flat in a piece published on 24 May 2023.