Benito Skinner promises ‘gayer’ Overcompensating season 2 as release date confirmed

Overcompensating season 2 is set to premiere in just a few months, and creator Benito Skinner has promised it’ll be “gayer” than the first.

The first season came out in May 2025, telling the story of closeted college freshman Benny (played by Skinner) as he navigates coming out while being in a new environment.

The comedy is set to return on 17 February, 2027, dealing with the aftermath of THAT cliffhanger finale, which saw Benny’s friend Carmen (Wally Baram) out him to his sister Grace (Mary Beth Barone).

Speaking to Vanity Fair, Skinner said they are “having more fun” in season 2, as Benny has lost some of the stress he was carrying.

He said “a few gays” told him they thought the show would be “gayer”, and he promises to deliver with season 2, saying: “We’re creeping out of the closet.”

What happens in Overcompensating season 2?

Season 2 of Overcompensating will see Benny return home with Grace for the Christmas break, still hiding his sexuality from the rest of his family.

His dad, played by Kyle McLachlan, finds out in a tense moment, with Benny going to extreme lengths to try and repair their bond.

Skinner says: “That relationship between gay men and father, I think, is always fraught and confusing. I just wanted to make it as honest as possible.”

It’s not just Benny’s relationship with his dad in a rocky patch though, as his friendship with Carmen is rough, and Grace and her boyfriend Peter (Adam DiMarco) have also split up.

The second season will explore the reality of coming out – the fact it’s not just a one and done sort of situation.

Skinner says: “I get to be even more specific about coming out and also tell a story that I think I haven’t seen yet done in this way, which is the complication of coming out – how you can take 10 steps forward, a hundred steps back.”

There’s also going to be plenty of sex scenes “that are definitely going to be off-limits for the family”, he adds.

Who is in Overcompensating season 2?

As well as the returning cast, a number of new faces have been confirmed for Overcompensating season 2.

Charlie and the Chocolate Factory star AnnaSophia Robb will play the coxswain of Benny’s crew team, while Tom Francis will play the team’s captain – and also be Benny’s new love interest.

Aisha Dee, from The Bold Type, also joins as the new It-girl on campus.

Robbie GK, who appeared in season 1 before he appeared in mega-hit Heated Rivalry, will not return as his schedule didn’t allow it.

Overcompensating is available to stream on Prime Video, with season 2 launching 17 February, 2027.

Share your thoughts! Let us know in the comments below, and remember to keep the conversation respectful.