Andrew Scott addresses chance he could be first out gay Best Actor Oscar winner

Andrew Scott WSJ. Magazine

Andrew Scott has addressed the buzz around his new film Elsinore, which has had critics suggesting he’s “all but secured” an Oscar.

The actor, who came out as gay publicly in a 2013 interview, plays Ian Charleson in the biographical movie, which is scheduled for release on 29 January, 2027 in the UK. It follows actor Charleson as he grapples with portraying Hamlet at the National Theatre, while living with the effects of AIDS.

Critics have heaped praise on his performance, so much so that there is talk he may win Best Actor at the 2027 Oscars, which would make him the first out gay actor to do so.

However, it appears he does not want to think too much into it, as, speaking to WSJ. Magazine, Scott said: “I don’t feel like I have to say anything about that, because the statistic speaks for itself.”

Out gay actors have been nominated for an Academy Award in the past, such as Colman Domingo for Sing Sing and Rustin, and Sir Ian McKellen for Gods and Monsters, however none have won.

Andrew Scott for WSJ. Magazine
Andrew Scott spoke of his new film, Elsinore (Robbie Lawrence for WSJ. Magazine)

Andrew Scott on playing straight

Andrew Scott is best known for roles in Sherlock, Fleabag (as the “hot priest”) and Netflix series Ripley.

In more recent years, he has had a number of gay roles, including in the heartbreaking movie All of Us Strangers, opposite Paul Mescal, and as a naughty therapist/hook-up in drama series It Gets Worse.

In Elsinore, Scott plays actor Ian Charleson, who did not publicly come out during his life. The actor died at the age of 40 on 6 January, 1990 of AIDS-related issues, after being diagnosed with HIV in 1986. He asked that the cause of his death be shared publicly to raise awareness of it.

Although Scott is out publicly, he does not judge Charleson for his decision not to come out, instead understanding the frustration he must have felt of having to choose between his career and identity.

He said: “I felt like I’ve got an understanding of what my failings are and what my strengths are. And I’ve never felt that it was beyond my reach to play a straight part.”

Andrew Scott for WSJ. Magazine
Critics have heaped praise on Andrew Scott’s performance in Elsinore (Robbie Lawrence for WSJ. Magazine)

What are critics saying about Elsinore?

Following a London Film Festival screening in early October, critics heaped praise on Scott’s performance in Elsinore.

In his review, The Times’ Kevin Maher wrote that Scott “has all but secured the Best Actor trophy,” adding: “You’ll barely be able to see the screen through the tears.”

The Guardian’s Benjamin Lee called Scott “astonishing”, writing that watching him “resiliently try to not cave in to what his body is telling him” is “an utterly heartbreaking trial to watch”.

Elsinore is released in UK cinemas on 29 January, 2027.

Share your thoughts! Let us know in the comments below, and remember to keep the conversation respectful.

Please login or register to comment on this story.