Man prosecuted for being gay breaks down as Nicola Sturgeon apologises

A man prosecuted for being gay has told of his relief after politicians apologised for historic anti-gay laws.

Nick Duffy and husband Phil Duffy were filmed clutching one another and weeping as Scotland’s First Minister Nicola Sturgeon “categorically, unequivocally and wholeheartedly” apologised for the former offences.

Consensual homosexual acts between men over the age of 21 were only made legal in Scotland in 1981, leaving thousands of men with criminal records because of their sexuality.

Sturgeon’s speech came as a bill was introduced which will automatically pardon gay and bisexual men convicted under historical laws.

Speaking to STV’s Scotland Tonight, Nick Duffy said he was “overwhelmed” by the apology, adding: “It matters so much because for the first time I am living in a country which accepts me as I am.”

The Scottish resident was convicted in England, where a similar pardon has been issued.

He said: “Every time I applied for a job – say as a teacher – they’d want to do a police check on me.

“And of course you’d be really scared something would appear on the police check.”

He added: “I did some counselling for quite a long time after I retired from teaching.

“They need police checks and they need them every year. All those sorts of things you send in the form hoping to goodness nobody is going to spot it or whatever.

“I’m glad to say I never got noted for anything, but you live with that fear every time.”

The pardon for gay men was pledged by Sturgeon in September.

Addressing the Scottish parliament, Sturgeon said: “Today as First Minister I categorically, unequivocally and wholeheartedly apologise for those laws and for the hurt and the harm that they caused to so many.

“Nothing that this Parliament does can erase those injustices, but I do hope this apology, alongside our new legislation, can provide some comfort to those who endured those injustices.

“And I hope that it provides evidence of this Parliament’s determination in so far as we can to address the harm that was done.”

The proposals were committed to by former SNP deputy leader Angus Robertson at the 2016 PinkNews Awards .

Former SNP MP John Nicolson also tried to push a similar bill through Westminster.

Meanwhile thousands of men in England and Wales were pardoned following the introduction of a similar law earlier this year.

EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - NOVEMBER 07: First Minister Nicola Sturgeon arrives at the Scottish Parliament,where she gave a formal apology to gay men on November 7, 2017 in Edinburgh, Scotland. The statement coincided with a new legislation that will automatically pardon gay and bisexual men convicted under historical laws. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)


Justice Secretary Michael Matheson said: “These discriminatory laws, although abolished, continue to have implications for people to this day and it is only right that we address this historic wrong, which criminalised people simply because of who they loved.

“I am pleased to introduce this bill, which is an important step towards correcting that injustice.”

Kezia Dugdale, who was the Scottish Labour Party leader when the legislation was announced, told Holyrood today that “apologies in this place are often offered through gritted teeth”.

She added that they often “follow a period of acrimony where one party has actively pursued and proven a mistake or a flaw, a diversion or hidden truth – even a scandal.

LIVERPOOL, ENGLAND - SEPTEMBER 26: Kezia Dugdale, leader of the Scottish Labour Party, addresses delegates on the second day of the annual Labour party conference at the ACC on September 26, 2016 in Liverpool, England. Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell has stated that if in power a Labour government would create a 'manufacturing renaissance'. Labour would also support traditional manufacturing and industry with government 'intervention' if needed. Mr McDonnell has also rejected claims that the party is anti-enterprise. (Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)


“This apology is very different. It’s offered with warmth and in the spirit of love and inclusion.

“It takes a deep breath and a big heart to say sorry for mistakes of the past.

“An even bigger heart when those errors are not your own.

“So I offer the congratulations and gratitude of these benches to the government for stepping up and saying sorry today.”

She pointed out that while “it has never been a crime for two women to be together,” that doesn’t mean women who have sex with women haven’t been on the receiving end of discrimination.

EDINBURGH, SCOTLAND - SEPTEMBER 12: Former Scottish Labour leader Kezia Dugdale arrives for Scottish Brexit minister Mike Russell statement to MSPs at the Scottish Parliament on the government's opposition to the EU Withdrawal bill as it stands on September 12, 2107 in Edinburgh, Scotland. Mr Russel set out the Scottish governments concerns over the EU Withdrawal Bill, which won its first Commons vote in the early hours of this morning. (Photo by Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Images)


“The history books teach us that lawmakers did try, in fact the House of Commons passed an amendment in 1921 to make sex between two women illegal but it was rejected by the House of Lords – because they didn’t want ordinary women to know that such a thing existed,” she said.

“Very often women had to pass as men to live their lives and if they were caught, they were sometimes convicted of fraud.

“Most were not criminalised for their love of each other, but they were still punished. They were both invisible and demeaned.

“Ostracised from their communities and families. Punished and painted out of history.”

Tim Hopkins, director of the LGBT charity Equality Network, said: “This very welcome bill will be of direct importance to hundreds of people with past criminal convictions for the kinds of relationships that were perfectly legal for their heterosexual friends.

GLASGOW, SCOTLAND - AUGUST 19: First Minister Nicola Sturgeon addresses the assembled crowd at Glasgow Pride on August 19, 2017 in Glasgow, Scotland. The largest festival of LGBTI celebration in Scotland is held every year in Glasgow since 1996. (Photo by Robert Perry/Getty Images)


“More widely, it is a clear statement that Scotland considers the discrimination of the past to be wrong and unacceptable, and now understands LGBTI people to be equal citizens who deserve equal respect.”

This year marks the 50th anniversary of the partial decriminalisation of gay sex in England and Wales, but Scottish gay and bi men had to wait another 14 years.

Consensual gay sex was only decriminalised in 1981 in Scotland, and gay and bi men had to wait until 2001 for an equal age of cosecant with heterosexual couples.