MPs urge Rishi Sunak to ditch ‘unlawful’ plan to make schools out trans children
The government has been accused of trying to flout the law with hardline new guidance restricting trans students in schools.
Education secretary Gillian Keegan confirmed on Wednesday (19 July) that the government intends to make schools out trans children to their parents.
She told Robert Peston the government thinks “parental consent is important” when it comes to children expressing a different gender identity at school.
Keegan said that guidance to that effect is forthcoming but has been delayed, appearing to confirm report that the government is attempting to work out the legalities.
The Times reported on Tuesday (18 July) that the government intended to introduce a “blanket ban” on social transition at school, but had been warned by the attorney general that this would be illegal because the Equality Act offers specific protections to trans people.
Opposition MPs and trans advocacy groups have warned the government that any attempt to restrict young trans people from expressing their gender identity would be detrimental to their wellbeing – and that it could have “unintended consequences” for cis children too.
You may like to watch
Kate Osborne, Labour MP for Jarrow, accused the government of trying to “flout the law” by issuing guidance instead of amending pre-existing legislation.
“Sunak should accept the legal advice, that he commissioned, that any attempts to effectively end the protected characteristic of being trans would breach the Equality Act,” Osborne told PinkNews.
“This government must stop trying to tie teachers’ hands behind their backs when students approach them for support.
“A blanket ban on social transitioning would be unlawful and as well as having a significant impact on trans students could have unintended consequences even just for girls who want to wear trousers or for students that for whatever reason want to change their names.
“Just like the proposed guidance for civil servants from last week, this is just another deliberate attempt to incite hatred as part of the Government’s war on woke.
“Their clear goal is to make the next general election a distraction culture war to cover up their disastrous 13 years of chaotic rule that has led to this cost of living crisis and rampant inflation.”
Nadia Whittome, Labour MP for Nottingham East, urged the government to scrap the guidance completely.
“For many young trans people, their ability to socially transition is essential to their mental health and wellbeing,” Whittome said.
“Any attempt by government to prevent them from cutting their hair or using a different name and pronouns is authoritarian and discriminatory in the extreme.
“The government should abandon this guidance now, along with its wider attacks on the trans community, and focus on improving trans people’s wellbeing and inclusion in society.”
Banning social transition at school would be ‘unenforceable’
Cleo Madeleine, spokesperson for trans advocacy charity Gendered Intelligence, hit out at fearmongering and misinformation about what socially transitioning actually means.
“Really what we’re talking about with social transition is young people changing things like hairstyle, make-up, clothing, to explore a different sort of gender presentation,” she explained.
“I think what’s really important is to note that none of this is new. Youth and adolescence in particular has always been a time when young people figure out who they are, explore different ways of presenting themselves to the world.
“Young people often play around with new names, with new ways of presenting themselves to the world – and that’s really all we’re talking about here.
“I think that’s what’s quite worrying with some of these conversations about the guidance is the idea that we’d be looking at regulating or even outright banning that natural process of exploration.”
Madeleine said that any ban on social transition in schools would be unworkable.
“There’s no way that a ban on students transitioning in schools could be implemented because it would amount to a ban on students being trans and that’s simply not enforceable.”
Tammy Hymas, policy and campaigns manager for Mermaids, warned that preventing trans and non-binary children from socially transitioning would “embolden bullies” and “weaken” teachers’ ability to protect students.
“This harms all children in schools because what it says is that you’re confined to a very narrow set of gender roles, a very narrow set of gender behaviours,” Hymas said.
She added: “There’s a lot of evidence that shows that social transition can be a very positive experience for young people. It gives them agency and it gives them choices about themselves and everyone would agree that that is an important and positive thing for young people.
“There’s actually some evidence which shows that even amongst children who don’t go on to transition in a permanent way that social transition and the affirmation and validation of that can be a positive experience.
“On the flip side when children don’t have their social transition validated, they don’t have it affirmed, we see that there’s much higher levels of mental health problems. We see that they experience more absenteeism and more pressure in their lives because of that.
“This is a question of listening to children and listening to the needs of young people, and I think at the moment it’s been blown out of all proportion by a government which seems to have a very clear ideological approach which is to discriminate and diminish the lives of trans people.”
PinkNews has contacted No 10 and the Department for Education for comment.
MyPinkNews members are invited to comment on articles to discuss the content we publish, or debate issues more generally. Please familiarise yourself with our community guidelines to ensure that our community remains a safe and inclusive space for all.