South African church accused of beating gay men half to death and forcing them to pay for ‘damages’

(Photo by RODGER BOSCH/AFP/GettyImages)

A South African church has been accused of beating gay men and then forcing them to pay a “damages” fee for shaming the church with their sexuality.

Some members of the Shembe Nazareth church have stepped forward and claimed that they were severely beaten after their sexuality was revealed.

South Africa Pride parade (Getty)

South Africa Pride parade (Getty)

Related: London council to spend millions remodelling hall for anti-gay Evangelical Church

One member, Dumisani Ngcobo, says that he is one of 50 men who were allegedly attacked within the church, forced to pay a fee and then ousted.

Ngcobo claims that a preacher within their church beat him after he accidentally touched another man while searching for his phone.

He was on a church retreat to Ekhenana Mountain and was sleeping in a tent with a number of other males from the same church when he misplaced his phone.

“He was sleeping next to me. While I searched for my phone I touched him. I had no bad intentions but I couldn’t find the phone. Accidently I touched him and he assumed I was playing naughty,” he explained.


Related: 93-year-old new Mormon leader claims the church loves gay people

Ngcobo claims that after the incident he was called in front of the minister and elders of the church to answer to the accusation that he is gay.

“The preacher had warned me that if I didn’t plead guilty he would kill me. I did admit I touched him. I was saving my life. I said I touched him intentionally.”

“After that I was called into a room. The preacher told me to take off my church robe. I lay down on a straw mat. He took a huge stick and started beating me.

“I was beaten from the head to the legs. He went on until I was helpless. I was numb and I was bleeding from head to toe. He told me to leave and never look back.”

The church has denied the claims put forward by Ngcobo, with a spokesperson saying that it would be “unacceptable” for someone to be beaten in the church because of their sexuality.

However, they did admit that they charge members a fee if they are thought to have brought shame onto the church.

A group of people from the gay, lesbian and transgender community in South Africa demonstrate outside the Parliament in Cape Town, on May 19, 2012. The protesters gathered to oppose the proposal by the House of Traditional Leaders to remove the term "sexual orientation" from section 9 (3) of the South African Constitution, which prohibits unfair discrimination. AFP PHOTO / RODGER BOSCH (Photo credit should read RODGER BOSCH/AFP/GettyImages)


Related: I married a woman, I tried to be a ‘good Christian’ – but nothing could change my sexuality

An anonymous source corroborated Ngcobo’s story to the South African Times.

They said that the violence is commonplace within the church, but unlike Ngcobo, most people are too scared of speaking out about it.

“They used sticks. We were taken into hospitals close to homes. My family knows but they are silencing everything.

“They are scared of shaming the church. But we have been silent enough about this. Being gay does not mean we are not humans,” the source said.

Ngcobo’s brother added that they saw Ngcobo after he was beaten and he was left with severe wounds.

“We were shocked when he arrived home. He was severely bleeding from the head. My aunt had to take care of the wounds and the bleeding.

“If my brother is gay, they should have dealt with that like a church. The South African Constitution supports gay men. They have rights like any of us. Beating a person because of his sexuality is a crime,” he added.