JK Rowling wants you to think any cis man can simply get a Gender Recognition Certificate and live as a trans woman. She’s wrong
JK Rowling wants you to think that the process to receive a Gender Recognition Certificate is so simple that any cis man can get one – but this is not true.
In the essay, Rowling claimed that the “current explosion of trans activism is urging a removal of almost all the robust systems through which candidates for sex reassignment were once required to pass”.
She added: “A man who intends to have no surgery and take no hormones may now secure himself a Gender Recognition Certificate and be a woman in the sight of the law. Many people aren’t aware of this.”
JK Rowling and her claims about the Gender Recognition Act are misleading.
Rowling’s claim is misleading.
For a trans person to be legally recognised in their gender, they must submit an application to the Gender Recognition Panel to obtain a Gender Recognition Certificate.
As part of the application process, trans people are required to provide a medical report from a doctor detailing any treatment they have had to date to change their gender, such as hormone treatment or surgery.
If they have not had any treatment or surgery, they must send a report that details what treatment they plan to have and explain the reasons why this has not yet happened.
While it is possible to receive a Gender Recognition Certificate without having had surgery or hormones, these occasions are rare, and the Gender Recognition Panel must be satisfied with an applicant’s explanation as to why treatment is not necessary. This process itself is a long and difficult one.
To get to this stage, an applicant must have already socially transitioned for two years and have been medically diagnosed with gender dysphoria. They muse also be aged 18 or over and agree to live the rest of their lives in the gender to which they are transitioning. JK Rowling’s assessment of the process has been simplified significantly. It’s not the case that a cis man can simply be recognised as a trans woman in the eyes of the late – it takes years of social transitioning and approval from satisfied medical professionals.
The law around gender recognition in the UK has not actually changed since it was first introduced in 2004.
LGBT+ rights organisations have been calling for change to the legislation for some time.
The Gender Recognition Act has undergone a review process in the last number of years in England, Scotland and Wales, but as of yet, none of the proposed changes have been enacted.
In 2018, a public consultation on the Gender Recognition Act ran over the course of 16 weeks in the UK, where citizens were encouraged to submit testimony.
Meanwhile, in Scotland, the government proposed a draft bill to reform the Act last year and launched a public consultation – but as of yet, nothing has changed for trans people.
Furthermore, under the law, non-binary and gender non-conforming people are not entitled to any form of gender recognition, and must legally be identified as either male or female.
LGBT+ rights organisations have been calling for changes to the legislation for several years now.
Stonewall, for example, wants the UK government to simplify the gender recognition process by allowing trans people to be legally recognised without a medical diagnosis.
They have also called for legal recognition of non-binary identities, as well as the right to self-identification for 16 and 17-year-olds.
If proposed changes to the Gender Recognition Act were brought in, the process would be streamlined for trans people in an effort to remove the bureaucratic burden currently placed on them.
Furthermore, the proposed changes would bring the UK’s Gender Recognition Act in line with other countries, including the Republic of Ireland, Norway, Malta, Denmark and Belgium.
JK Rowling’s comments risk making it sound as if trans people can easily have their gender legally recognised by law in the UK – but right now, this is far from the truth.
Update: An earlier version of this article contained an inaccuracy surrounding the Gender Recognition Act and the process through which trans people may acquire a Gender Recognition Certificate. PinkNews is happy to have corrected this and updated with relevant information.
MyPinkNews members are invited to comment on articles to discuss the content we publish, or debate issues more generally. Please familiarise yourself with our community guidelines to ensure that our community remains a safe and inclusive space for all.