The UK has rejected thousands of gay asylum seekers
Data quietly published by the UK government today shows that thousands of gay, lesbian and bisexual asylum seekers have been refused asylum from countries where they could face prison, violence, or death.
After facing repeated calls to release data on its treatment of gay asylum seekers, the Home Office finally released a report on the issue today for the first time.
The astonishing data, which the Home Office describes as “experimental”, shows that thousands of gay and lesbian asylum seekers have been turned away over the past two years.
A total of 3,535 asylum applications were made by people fleeing persecution at least partly based on their sexual orientation, amounting to 6 percent of asylum claims.
However, more than two-thirds of these were rejected.
Of cases with a clear resolution, 2,379 claims were rejected, and just 838 approved.
The data also shows that asylum claims were rejected from gay people who fled persecution under some of the most violent homophobic regimes on the planet.
84 people from Iran, where homosexuality is punishable by death, were denied asylum – nearly half of all of those who applied.
The Home Office accepted just 63 gay asylum seekers from Nigeria, where gay people can face extreme violence or decades in jail. 268 gay Nigerians were turned away.
108 applications from gay asylum seekers fleeing Uganda, where gay sex is punishable by seven years in prison, were also rejected.
Not a single applicant from India or Sri Lanka, where homosexuality is a crime, was accepted – despite 82 and 48 applications respectively.
The majority of asylum seekers from Iraq, Afghanistan, Zimbabwe, Kenya and Jamaica were also turned away.
The data raises serious questions for Prime Minister Theresa May, who was Home Secretary for much of the time period and oversaw the asylum system.
Mrs May carried out a ‘review’ of the regulations for LGBT asylum seekers while serving as Home Secretary, but the system has been repeatedly exposed as discriminatory and failing.
The Home Office procedures for processing LGBT asylum seekers has been repeatedly criticised by campaigners over inconsistent standards that “humiliate” applicants, and often leave people facing deportation to countries where they face persecution for their sexuality.
One lesbian asylum seeker was told she couldn’t be gay because she has children, while another asylum seeker was compelled to show caseworkers explicit pictures of himself having gay sex to ‘prove’ his sexuality.
Another bisexual man, who fled from persecution in his home country, had his application challenged by the Home Office because he said the T in LGBT stood for ‘Trans’ as opposed to ‘Transgender’.
Many LGBT asylum seekers have been scheduled for deportation and told to go home and ‘act straight’.
The dataset relates to asylum cases raised between 1 July 2015 and 31 March 2017. No data is available for earlier asylum cases.
The Home Office said: “These data are experimental statistics and should be interpreted with caution. Experimental statistics are statistics that are in a testing phase and are not yet fully developed.
“These statistics have not been subject to the full level of quality assurance of National Statistics.”
It adds that “a claim may be based on multiple factors” and that “the outcome of the claim may not be down to the sexual orientation component”.
Lord Scriven, Liberal Democrat Lords Spokesperson for International LGBT Rights, told PinkNews: “This is a record of shame for the government.
“This data reveals how vulnerable LGBT asylum seekers are when trying to claim safety and freedom here in the UK. Now we know why the Government have dragged their feet on releasing this data.
“Many of those people denied by the British Government are returning to places where they face harassment, imprisonment and even death just because of who they are.
“The Liberal Democrats will challenge the Government over these figures.
“It is proof that the UK is failing to offer a safe place of sanctuary for those fleeing violence and danger only for loving a person of the same sex.”
Paul Dillane, executive director of Kaleidoscope Trust, told PinkNews: “Around the world, LGBT people face discrimination and violence on a daily basis on account of their sexuality or gender identity. As a result, many people are forced to flee in search of protection in other countries.
“Until today, and despite well-documented instances of discrimination, disbelief and detention experienced by LGBT asylum seekers, it has been impossible to answer the simple question: how many LGBT people seek asylum in the UK?”
He added: “After years of intensive lobbying, the UK Home Office have finally published statistics.
“This is a welcome step forward but they raise a series of concerns: the statistics do not provide any information as to why a person seeking asylum on account of their sexuality was refused, trans people are excluded entirely and we do not know how many people were detained upon seeking asylum. Given the terrible abuses experienced by LGBT people in immigration detention, this is an issue which requires urgent attention.”
“54% of Ugandans and 39% of Pakistanis were granted asylum on appeal indicating many lesbian, gay and bisexual asylum seekers were only granted refugee protection after being initially refused and taking their case to court: an expensive, timely and stressful process.”
“Asylum claims by LGBT people are often matters of life or death. We urge the UK Home Office to take proactive steps to improve standards, training and the quality of decision-making to ensure LGBT people fleeing persecution are genuinely respected and protected.”
A Stonewall spokesperson said: “Lesbian, gay, bi and trans people face violence and persecution in many countries around the world, and many flee in fear of their lives.
“It’s vital those seeking asylum in the UK are treated fairly and with respect.
“These new figures show that many applications for asylum from countries where LGBT face violence were rejected. This is deeply troubling; what we don’t know from the report is why they were rejected.”
Stonewall added: “We’re calling on the Government to do more to ensure that asylum claims from LGBT people are treated fairly and with respect.
“This means an end to rules that allow LGBT people to be sent back if it is perceived they can escape violence by keeping their sexuality or gender identity secret.
“It means better and more training for officers to deal with claims sensitively, and it also means an end to the detention of LGBT asylum seekers. It’s devastating that so many people experience shocking abuse and violence in a country where they hoped to escape it.”
But Immigration Minister Brandon Lewis insisted: “This Government is committed to an asylum system which is supportive and responsive to those claiming asylum on the basis of their sexual orientation.
“All asylum claims lodged in the UK, including those on the grounds of sexuality, are carefully considered in accordance with our international obligations. Decision-makers are given dedicated training and guidance on how to handle such claims.
“No one who is found to be at risk of persecution or serious harm in their country of origin because of their sexuality will be returned.”
Out MP Joanna Cherry raised the issue during Prime Minister’s Questions last month, off the back of the Prime Minister’s landmark appearance at the PinkNews Awards, where she declared that “LGBT rights are human rights”.
Ms Cherry said: “We can all agree that no one should ever be persecuted on account of their sexuality.
“At the PinkNews Awards, the Prime Minister said we have come a long way on LGBT rights, but there’s still much more to do.
“Can I ask her to start that work today by promising that never again will the Home Office deport LGBT Asylum Seekers to countries where they are likely to be persecuted with the instruction that they pretend to be straight?”
The Prime Minister did not provide a direct assurance in her response.
She responded: “Can I say to the honourable lady that this is an issue that we take seriously, and I think I’m right in saying that it was a Conservative government that actually changed the rules on Asylum seeking to introduce the category of those who could face persecution in their home of origin because of their sexuality.”
She added: “I’m pleased that this was able to be done and I want the Home Office treats all the cases with the sensitivity that is appropriate.”
A court ruling earlier this year suggested that under Mrs May’s leadership, the Home Office may have illegally deported gay asylums seekers.
Speaking at the PinkNews Awards, the Prime Minister said: “Britain has come far in fifty years, but we know there is still a long way to go.
“Homophobia, biphobia and transphobia have still not been defeated, and they must be.”
She added: “When we look around the world, we see countries where the human rights of LGBT people are denied and terrible suffering is the result.
“On the world stage, we are standing up for LGBT rights, and challenging at the highest level those governments which allow or inflict discrimination or abuse.
“The anti-LGBT laws which remain in some Commonwealth countries are a legacy of Britain’s colonial past, so the UK Government has a special responsibility to help change hearts and minds and we will ensure that these important issues are discussed at the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting, which we will be hosting here in London next April and also during our two years as Commonwealth Chair in Office.”
She added: “So, let me be absolutely clear. We have come a long way – but there is much still to do.
“The Government has a plan to deliver, and I am committed to ensuring that we work that through.
“Because LGBT history is all our history, LGBT success is everyone’s success, and LGBT rights are human rights.”
MyPinkNews members are invited to comment on articles to discuss the content we publish, or debate issues more generally. Please familiarise yourself with our community guidelines to ensure that our community remains a safe and inclusive space for all.